Car Insurance in Buffalo, NY - The Zebra
5 days ago · The average rate in Buffalo is $209/mo. New York Central Mutual Fire offers the cheapest car insurance in Buffalo at $114/mo. Compare quotes and save on auto insurance …
Cheapest Car Insurance in Buffalo for 2025 - NerdWallet
Here are the cheapest car insurance companies in Buffalo, New York for 2025 for a variety of ages and zip codes.
Best car insurance in Buffalo, NY (2024) - Policygenius
Jan 1, 2026 · In order to get cheaper car insurance in Buffalo, you should compare the cost of coverage from multiple companies near you. You should also look for insurers in Buffalo that …
Best Car Insurance Rates in Buffalo, NY - ValuePenguin
Jul 8, 2025 · What's the best car insurance coverage in Buffalo, NY? Full coverage car insurance is the best choice for most people, because it will pay for damage to your car in a crash or due …
Cheapest Car Insurance Companies in Buffalo, NY (From $101)
Mar 1, 2021 · Find the most affordable car insurance quotes in Buffalo from Liberty Mutual, Erie, USAA, and others. Rates refreshed as of January 2026.
- Reviews: 414
Best Cheap Car Insurance in Buffalo, NY (2026) - MoneyGeek
Dec 29, 2025 · Buffalo drivers pay some of New York's highest car insurance rates, with premiums varying across the city's ZIP codes. We designed our research to find insurers …
Cheap Car Insurance in Buffalo, NY, Starting at $101
5 days ago · Compare the cheapest car insurance quotes in Buffalo from Liberty Mutual, Erie, USAA, and more. Quotes updated January 2026
- Reviews: 2.3K
Best Local Car Insurance Agencies in Buffalo, NY - Expertise.com
5 days ago · Find and connect with the 17 Best Local Car Insurance Agencies in Buffalo, NY. Hand picked by an independent editorial team and updated for 2026.
Average car insurance cost in Buffalo, New York - Insure.com
Dec 18, 2025 · Looking for the best rates on car insurance in Buffalo, New York? Compare prices from top auto insurance companies and save big on your insurance policy today.
Cheap Car Insurance Rates in Buffalo, New York | SmartFinancial
Dec 1, 2025 · Understand the average rate quotes for drivers like you or the cheapest car insurance within Buffalo, New York. Request free insurance quotes today!